The involvement of several nations, each with its own tax laws, regulatory environment, and business practices, makes cross-border mergers and acquisitions (M&A) transactions naturally complicated. To guarantee best results for the interested parties, it is vital to structure these transactions in a tax-efficient manner. This need for knowledge of the tax consequences at several levels and across several nations.
The following is an overview of the tax considerations and structure choices in cross-border M&A deals:
Type of Mergers and acquisitions
The ways in which M&A transactions can be undertaken are:
1. Amalgamation or Merger: This entails a court-approved process whereby one or more companies merge with another company, or two or more companies merge, to form one company.
2. Demerger: This entails a court-approved process whereby the business or undertaking of one company is demerged out of that company, into a resulting company.
3. Share Purchase: This envisages the purchase of shares of a target company by an acquirer.
4. Slump Sale: This entails a sale of a business or undertaking by a seller as a going concern to an acquirer, without specific values being assigned to individual assets; and
5. Asset Sale: An asset sale is yet another way to transfer a company; it involves a buyer cherry-picking individual assets or liabilities.
Tax considerations in Cross Border M&A:
Varying tax laws, treaties, and rules across several jurisdictions makes tax issues in cross-border mergers and acquisitions (M&A) complicated. Some of the main tax problems that frequently come up in cross-border M&A deals are listed below:
1. Tax Residency:
A. Determining Tax Residency of Entities-
i. Incorporation and Place of Management
ii. Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAAs)
iii. Transfer Pricing
B. Impact on the M&A Structure:
i. If a company is restructured or moves its tax residency as part of an M&A, the transaction may be treated as a taxable event. This could lead to capital gains tax or other taxation of the transfer of assets, including intellectual property (IP), goodwill, and other intangible assets.
ii. A shift in tax residency might also trigger exit taxes or withholding taxes on dividends, interest, or royalties.
C. Tax Considerations for Shareholders:
i. The tax treatment of dividends, capital gains, and any repatriation of profits may be influenced by the tax residency of the acquiring or target entity. Different jurisdictions have different tax regimes, and if the buyer or seller is based in a low-tax jurisdiction, tax efficiency can be optimized.
2. International Tax Considerations:
A. Withholding Taxes: Cross-border M&As may involve payments such as dividends, interest, and royalties, which could be subject to withholding taxes by the source country.
B. Exit Taxes: In some cases, jurisdictions may impose exit taxes when a company moves its tax residency from one country to another or transfers significant assets out of the country.
C. Tax Treatment of Cross-Border Mergers: M&A transactions may benefit from tax reliefs such as rollover relief or tax deferral provisions in certain countries.
D. Taxation of Gains on Sale of Shares:
a. Seller’s Taxation on Capital Gains (Share Sale):
i. Source Country Taxation: The jurisdiction where the shares are located (usually the country of incorporation of the target company) typically has the right to tax the capital gains from the sale of shares.
ii. Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA): If there is a tax treaty between the seller's home country and the jurisdiction where the target company is incorporated, the treaty may allocate taxing rights.
iii. Participation Exemption: Some countries have a participation exemption regime, which may exempt capital gains from the sale of shares if the seller holds a substantial interest in the target company (usually defined as a certain percentage of shares or voting rights).
iv. Exit Tax (on Repatriation): In certain cases, a country may levy an exit tax on capital gains when a company’s tax residence changes or when assets are transferred abroad (such as when a company is moved to a different jurisdiction post-M&A).
b. Buyer’s Considerations (Share Sale):
i. Step-Up in Basis: If the transaction involves a share purchase, the buyer usually acquires the shares at the purchase price (also called the step-up in basis).
ii. Tax-Free Reorganizations: In some jurisdictions, tax-free reorganizations may apply to the purchase of shares in certain M&A transactions, allowing the buyer to acquire shares without triggering immediate taxation.
E. Taxation of Gains on Sale of other Assets:
a. Seller’s Taxation on Capital Gains (Asset Sale):
i. Capital Gains Tax: When a seller sells assets in a cross-border M&A, the gain on the sale is generally taxed as a capital gain in the jurisdiction where the seller is tax resident.
ii. Depreciation Recapture: In many jurisdictions, if the seller has claimed depreciation deductions on the assets being sold, the sale could trigger depreciation recapture.
iii. Withholding Tax on Sale of Specific Assets: Some countries impose withholding tax on the sale of certain assets, such as real estate or IP, particularly if the asset is located within the country.
iv. Exit Taxes and Transfer Pricing: In cross-border asset sales, countries may impose exit taxes or require adjustments to the sale price if the assets are moved from one jurisdiction to another (especially in the case of intangible assets such as IP).
v. Local Taxes on Specific Assets: Jurisdictions may impose specific taxes on certain types of assets.
b. Buyer’s Considerations (Asset Sale):
i. Step-Up in Basis: This means that the buyer can depreciate or amortize the assets based on their fair market value (FMV) at the time of the acquisition, which could lead to significant tax deductions over time.
ii. Tax Deductions for Amortization and Depreciation: The buyer can generally claim depreciation or amortization deductions on the acquired assets, which may provide tax benefits, particularly for tangible assets or intangible assets (e.g., goodwill, patents, trademarks).
iii. Possible Transfer Taxes: Depending on the nature of the assets and the jurisdiction, the buyer may need to pay transfer taxes on certain assets (e.g., real estate or intellectual property). These taxes should be factored into the total transaction cost.
F. Foreign Tax Credits and Deductions:
i. Foreign Tax Credit: If a company is subject to foreign tax on its income, it may be eligible for a foreign tax credit in its home jurisdiction to offset the taxes paid abroad. This can help reduce the risk of double taxation.
ii. Deductions for Acquisition Costs: Some jurisdictions may allow the deduction of transaction-related expenses, including advisory, legal, and financing costs. The tax treatment of such expenses can vary significantly depending on the structure and location of the deal.
G. Financing and Tax Deductibility:
i. Debt Financing: Funding the acquisition with debt financing (leveraged buyout) could lead to interest payments that are tax-deductible in some areas. Interest deductibility, thereby, depends on local regulations and thin capitalization rules may restrict it by prohibiting too much debt.
ii. Thin Capitalization Rules: Countries have rules to prevent excessive debt financing by foreign companies, limiting interest deductions if the company’s debt-to-equity ratio exceeds a certain threshold.
H. Anti-Avoidance Rules:
i. General Anti-Avoidance Rules (GAAR): Many times, nations include GAAR provisions that limit tax evasion by means of unnatural or abusive structures. In cross-border M&A deals, these regulations are especially important since tax authorities could question transactions seen as unfairly intended to lower taxes.
ii. Controlled Foreign Corporation (CFC) Rules: CFC rules are meant to stop tax evasion by moving profits to low or no-tax jurisdictions. If the parent corporation owns a major interest in the overseas entity, they tax the revenue of foreign subsidiaries.
I. Double Taxation and Tax Treaties:
i. Double Taxation: Cross-border M&A can sometimes cause double taxation, or the taxation of the same income by both the home country and the foreign country.
ii. Tax Treaty Benefits: Tax treaties might let royalties, interest, and dividends be taxed favorably. Reducing tax exposure depends on finding and using the appropriate treaty clauses.
J. Withholding Taxes:
i. Dividends, Interest, and Royalties: Many countries impose withholding taxes on dividends, interest, and royalties paid to foreign entities.
ii. Repatriation of Funds: After the acquisition, repatriating profits from the acquired foreign entity to the home country may be subject to withholding taxes.
K. VAT/GST and Other Indirect Taxes:
i. Value Added Tax (VAT): In some jurisdictions, the sale of shares may be exempt from VAT, while the sale of assets could be subject to VAT or sales tax. Determining the VAT treatment of the transaction is important for cash flow purposes.
ii. Customs Duties: Cross-border asset transfers may be subject to customs duties, particularly if physical goods or assets are involved. The proper classification and valuation of goods are essential to avoid unexpected duties and taxes.
Jurisdictional considerations:
1. Choice of Jurisdiction for the M&A Transaction:
A. Legal Structure: Cross-border M&As can be structured in numerous ways, such as stock purchases, asset purchases, or mergers.
B. Regulatory Approval: Cross-border M&As may require approval from regulatory authorities in multiple jurisdictions.
a. Foreign Investment Laws: These regulations can limit the structure of the deal and may require special permission or conditions for the transaction to proceed.
b. Tax Jurisdiction of Assets: In cross-border M&As, it is critical to assess the tax rules concerning the jurisdiction of assets.
2. Cross-Border Legal Compliance:
A. Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Know Your Customer (KYC): Compliance with international anti-money laundering and anti-corruption laws becomes more complicated in a cross-border M&A, as each jurisdiction has its own standards and enforcement procedures.
B. Labour Laws: Labor rights in different jurisdictions may require the buyer to address issues related to the transfer of employees, such as pension obligations, severance pay, and continuity of employment.
C. Intellectual Property (IP): The jurisdiction of intellectual property rights (such as patents, trademarks, copyrights) is crucial because it determines the rights and protections available. Cross-border M&As may involve IP transfers, which may trigger complex tax implications, especially if the IP is transferred across high-tax jurisdictions or low-tax jurisdictions with different treatment.
D. Special Considerations for Cross-Border Asset Sales:
i. Withholding Taxes on Dividends, Royalties, and Interest: If the sale involves cross-border payments (e.g., royalties or interest from the use of intellectual property), the source country may impose withholding taxes.
ii. VAT/GST and Indirect Taxes: In many countries, the sale of assets (such as goods, services, or real property) is subject to Value Added Tax (VAT) or Goods and Services Tax (GST). The buyer and seller must consider whether the sale of certain assets triggers VAT/GST and how this will impact the overall transaction structure.
iii. Taxable or Tax-Free Asset Transfers: Some countries offer tax deferral or tax-free treatment for certain asset transfers, such as business reorganizations or asset swaps, which could potentially reduce the immediate tax liability of the seller.
Transfer Pricing considerations:
1. Arm's Length Principle: The arm's length principle is a cornerstone of transfer pricing. It dictates that the prices charged between related parties in cross-border transactions (such as the sale of assets, services, or intellectual property) must be comparable to the prices that would be charged between unrelated parties in similar circumstances. In an M&A context:
A. When determining the price for the sale of shares, assets, or services between the buyer and seller (or between related entities), both parties must justify that the terms of the transaction adhere to the arm's length standard.
B. Failure to comply with the arm's length principle can result in tax adjustments, penalties, or double taxation.
2. Valuation of Intangible Assets: The methods for determining the value of intangible assets include:
A. Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) Method: Compares the transaction to similar transactions involving third parties.
B. Profit Split Method: Allocates the combined profits between the buyer and seller based on their contribution to the intangible asset.
C. Residual Profit Split Method: Used when profits from the transaction are highly dependent on the intangible assets, such as in the case of high-tech companies.
Other considerations:
1. Cross-Border Financing and Debt Structures:
A. Interest Rate Determination: The interest rate charged on intercompany loans must be consistent with market rates, and it should reflect an arm's length range.
B. Thin Capitalization Rules: Some jurisdictions impose thin capitalization rules, which restrict the ability of a company to deduct excessive interest payments on intercompany loans.
C. Transfer Pricing Documentation: Proper documentation must be maintained to demonstrate that the intercompany financing arrangements are in line with arm's length principles.
2. Transfer of Contracts and Agreements:
A. Repricing of Contracts:
B. Service Agreements:
C. Licensing Agreements
3. Post-M&A Integration and Compliance: after the merger or acquisition, integration activities must ensure tax compliance across the jurisdictions involved. This includes aligning tax reporting, transfer pricing, VAT compliance, and corporate structures in accordance with local laws.
Thank you for getting in touch! 